What would you do if somebody keeps faking their identity and goes about telling people they lived your life and you lived theirs?

An internet user asked, “Will I be the jerk for telling my half-sister’s new family that she kind of assumed my identity?”. Here’s the full story for your context.


two Caucasian women arguing and distrusting each other
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

The Original Poster (OP) (F25) has a half-sister (F24), called ‘Hannah’. OP supposes from their ages the circumstances of her birth are very obvious, and because of this and the subsequent drama, she was never in OP’s life growing up.

What Does OP Say

Young caucasian overweight woman isolated on blue background confused and doubtful shrugging shoulders to hold a copy space.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

“I would say I’ve met her less than 10 times in my life. When she was 16 she started consistently reaching out to me via social media but I was never interested. This stopped when we were about 20.”, says OP.

Some Flashback

Image Credits: Deposit Photos.

Since then, OP mostly forgot about her existence until she reached out to OP again at the start of this year, saying she’d got engaged. She wanted OP to come to her engagement party and help her get in contact with the rest of OP’s dad’s side of the family.

OP Told She Wasn’t Interested

Young blond curly hair caucasian man isolated doubting and shrugging shoulders in questioning gesture.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

OP told her OP wasn’t interested but she did ask the rest of the family (granddad, aunts, cousins) if they wanted OP to put them in touch with her and they said no, so OP told her that, too.

About A Week Later

Young couple sitting on the sofa discussing at home.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

About a week later, OP got a message on social media from her sister’s fiancé, digging OP out for how she treated her.

He told OP he understood that it was tough being the product of an affair and he gets that OP would be jealous of her since OP was shunned by the family, but that she felt terrible about it and had always wanted a relationship with OP.

“I was as confused as I was angry because he had the entire story backward.”, says OP.

OP’s Response The First Time It Happened

Image Credits: Anetlanda, Shutterstock

OP forwarded the messages to Hannah with a question mark, and she admitted that her fiancé and his whole family don’t know that she is an affair baby, that they think she stayed in contact with dad’s family, that she went to the schools and university and lived the life OP did.

“I didn’t blast her for the lies, I just told her that if I ever heard from any of the people in her life again, I would tell them the truth.”, says OP.

A Few Days Ago

Two agressive women having argue fight being mad at each other. Female violance concept.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

The months went by. A few days ago, OP received more messages, from the fiancé and the fiancé’s sister, calling OP a heartless jerk for refusing Hannah’s attempts at contact. The sister said OP needed to get over her jealousy of Hannah.

The fiancé called out OP for ‘emotionally blackmailing’ Hannah’s dad into not going to the wedding. It took everything in OP not to reply and read a lot of them to filth.

OP’s Dilemma Right Now

Friends having a fight
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

So, now OP is contemplating whether she would be the jerk for messaging them back with the truth. It can’t go on like this, OP told Hannah to handle her business and she didn’t.

“Also, her lies are pretty weird. She’s marrying a guy who has no idea who she is. Then again, it’s not like she sent these people after me, so maybe I would be the jerk for tearing apart her whole life over something that isn’t technically her fault.”, says OP.

Now OP wants to know what must be her next steps in this scenario.

Tell Them The Truth And Block Them All

Young hispanic woman standing over pink background shooting and killing oneself pointing hand and fingers to head like gun, suicide gesture.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

“Not the jerk. Tell them the truth and block them all. You’re not tearing her life apart, she is. It is technically her fault that she lied to everyone. She not only lied but she outed you, and after having some family harass you, she still didn’t tell them the truth and let more family harass you.

She is perpetuating the lies even knowing you know she’s lying, and she’s adding more lies – she’s now making them think things are your fault! This is 100% on her.

Write up a message that’s the truth, simple and honest and then block anyone who contacts you from her side of the family.”

Time To Make Good On Your Promise

Don't know, sorry. Portrait of clueless uncertain confused curly-haired woman in urban style hoodie shrugging shoulders in questioning gesture, looking with indifference. indoor studio shot isolated
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

“At this point, I’d personally go all in and show your work. The timeline of the affair, who did what, why you don’t have a relationship. The whole thing. You didn’t solicit these messages. They opened the door, time to make good on your promise.

Also, Hannah is 100% aware of and encouraging these messages or they wouldn’t be happening. Not the jerk.”

This Girl Sounds Unhinged

Photo of confused puzzled lady wear striped pullover not understand you isolated teal color background.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

“Not the jerk. You should definitely tell them the truth and maybe see if it’s possible to get a restraining order, this girl sounds unhinged.

I speak from personal experience, my dad also had an affair daughter and she caused me and my brother a lot of trouble until dad got a restraining order against her (we were underage).

Where is your dad in all of this? He should go and talk to those people and ask them to stop harassing you.”

Give Her The Ultimatum Once More

Oops, what did I do? MODEL holding hand on forehead with frightened and regret expression.
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

“Not the jerk- You have warned her, and you have made it quite clear. Why should he be hounded for her own lies and guilt? Give her the ultimatum one more time, and should it continue, tell the truth only if it is not possible for you to block them all.”

More From Mrs Daaku Studio

Image Credits: Artazum, Shutterstock

Thrift stores and goodwill stores are great, but there are many weird instances of people finding things. Read – Goodwill Workers Share 16 “Weirdest” Things They’ve Ever Found, It’s Hilarious!

She Demands Her Sister Stop Wearing Silk Nightgowns. Says It’s Inappropriate. Should She Just Stop Wearing Them?

Two sisters teenager fighting at home angry pulling long hair
Image Credits: Deposit Photos

Sisters can be difficult sometimes, and here is one case for you to judge. Read – She Demands Her Sister Stop Wearing Silk Nightgowns. Says, “It’s Inappropriate.” Should She Just Stop Wearing Them?

Father Corrects Teacher’s Pronunciation of Daughter’s Name, School Accuses Him of Questioning Authority

Image Credits: Deposit Photos.

Schools can act arbitrarily sometimes, and here is a case. Read how this Father Corrects the Teacher’s Pronunciation of Daughter’s Name, School Accuses Him of ‘Questioning Authority’. Does This Make Sense?

He Inherited His Brother’s Insurance and 401K, Refused To Share It With Brother’s Widow and Kids. Thinks He Is Right

Portrait of an annoyed woman
Image Credit; Deposit Photos

He Inherited His Brother’s Insurance and; 401K. Refused To Share It With Brother’s Widow and Kids. Thinks He Is Right.Read more.

Woman Cancels Credit Card After Boyfriend REFUSES to Return It, Is This Financial Abuse?

angry hatred
Image Credits: Roman Samborskyi, Shutterstock

Woman Cancels Credit Card After Boyfriend REFUSES to Return It. Is This Financial Abuse? We think it is, but we need to hear from you. Read here.This article was originally published on Mrs Daaku Studio.

Similar Posts